CRU Certificates and Schedule of Loss in Personal Injury Trial Bundles

What CRU does and why it matters

The Compensation Recovery Unit operates within the DWP under the Social Security (Recovery of Benefits) Act 1997. Where a person receives State benefits as a result of an injury, the Act requires any compensator paying personal injury damages to repay the State for the benefits received during the relevant period. The compensator pays the full recoverable amount to DWP (s.6(1)) and may reduce only the parts of the compensation for lost earnings, cost of care and loss of mobility, never general damages (s.8, Sch 2).

The Act splits losses into three "heads": loss of earnings, cost of care, and loss of mobility. Different benefits can be recovered against different heads:

• Loss of earnings head — universal credit, disablement pension (s.103 SSCBA 1992), ESA, incapacity benefit, income support, JSA, SSP and the other benefits listed in Sch 2
• Cost of care head — attendance allowance, daily living component of PIP, care component of DLA, disablement pension increase
• Loss of mobility head — mobility components of PIP and DLA

Pain and suffering damages (general damages) are NOT recoverable against — these are protected. The deduction from the claimant cannot exceed the award for the matching heads (s.8(3)–(4)). The compensator remains liable to pay the whole certified amount (s.6(1)). Ring-fencing of general damages: Williams v Devon CC [2003] EWCA Civ 365.

---

How the certificate flows through a claim

The compensator's CRU process runs in parallel with the claim:

Notification — start of claim

When the compensator receives the Letter of Claim (or the equivalent, such as Stage 1 of the MoJ Portal), they notify CRU within 14 days using Form CRU1. CRU opens a case file and begins tracking benefits paid to the claimant.

Interim certificate — pre-settlement

The compensator can request a CRU certificate at any stage. Pre-trial, the certificate gives both sides a snapshot of the recoverable amount as of the certificate date. Used in:

• Part 36 offer drafting (the offer must engage with the certificate)
• Schedule of Loss / Counter-Schedule reconciliation
• Round-table negotiations and ADR

Final certificate — at settlement / judgment

A final CRU certificate is required at settlement or judgment. The certificate sets the figure the compensator must repay to CRU. The compensator deducts that figure (heads-matched) from the claimant's compensation and pays it directly to CRU; the claimant receives the net.

Validity period

Each certificate remains in force until the date specified in it (s.4(4)); fresh certificates may be requested (s.4(5)).

---

CRU and the Schedule of Loss

The Schedule of Loss is the claimant's tabulation of past and future losses. A CPR-aligned Schedule sets out:

The CRU certificate intersects the first three rows. A claimant who received £18,000 of incapacity-related benefits during the recovery period sees that figure deducted from the Loss of Earnings head before payment (up to the amount awarded for lost earnings: s.8).

The Counter-Schedule from the defendant typically argues for:

• Lower multiplicands (lower hours of care, lower care rates)
• Lower multipliers (longer life expectancy adjustments, residual earning capacity)
• Specific items disallowed (e.g. treatment the claimant has in fact received free on the NHS — the mere availability of NHS treatment is disregarded: Law Reform (Personal Injuries) Act 1948 s.2(4))
• The CRU recoverable as already paid (so deducted from any award before payment)

In the trial bundle, keep the CRU certificate with the Schedule and Counter-Schedule, paginated alongside them.

---

CRU and Part 36 offers

Part 36 offers in personal injury claims have a CRU layer. CPR rule 36.20 sets out the rules. A defendant must state either that the offer is made without regard to recoverable amounts, or that it includes deductible amounts, giving gross, deductible and net figures (r.36.20(3)–(6)). At trial the claimant fails to beat the offer if the judgment, after deducting deductible amounts identified in it, is not greater than the stated net amount (r.36.20(8)).

---

What goes in the trial bundle

A typical trial bundle for a quantum-stage PI hearing includes the CRU material with the Schedule of Loss and Counter-Schedule:

├── I1 — Claimant's Schedule of Loss
├── I2 — Defendant's Counter-Schedule
├── I3 — Most recent CRU certificate
├── I4 — CRU correspondence trail (where in dispute)
├── I5 — Joint statement of agreed and disputed quantum items
└── I6 — Authorities on quantum (Ogden, JC Guidelines references)

Each document is bookmarked. The hyperlinked index lets the trial judge jump from a schedule line to the supporting evidence in earlier sections (medical records in Section C, expert reports in Sections D-E, etc.).

---

Common errors

---

How BundleCreator helps

In BundleCreator's PI trial bundle template the schedule and counter-schedule sit with the statements of case; upload the most recent CRU certificate beside them.

The output is a single PDF with continuous pagination, OCR throughout, and bookmarks at section and document level — ready for the King's Bench Division clinical negligence list, the County Court multi-track, or the small claims track depending on the case.

---

Frequently asked questions

How long does CRU take to issue a certificate?

DWP must issue within four weeks of receiving the application (s.4(2)–(3)).

Can the claimant challenge the CRU certificate?

Yes. Ask DWP for a mandatory reconsideration. An appeal to the First-tier Tribunal can be made only after the claim is finally disposed of and the compensator has paid (s.11(3)). See DWP guide Z2 for time limits.

What if the claimant received NHS treatment?

Part 3 of the Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Act 2003 (which replaced the Road Traffic (NHS Charges) Act 1999) makes the compensator liable for NHS hospital treatment and ambulance charges in any injury claim (diseases are excluded unless attributable to the injury: s.150(1), (5)–(6)). The compensator pays the NHS via the Injury Cost Recovery Scheme. NHS charges are paid by the compensator in addition to damages and are not deducted from the claimant's compensation (s.150(2)).

How is interest on past losses calculated, and how does CRU affect it?

Interest on past losses runs at half the special account rate from the date of injury to the date of judgment. Interest on past losses is calculated without deducting benefits (Wadey v Surrey County Council [2000] 1 WLR 820 (HL)).

Does CRU apply to clinical negligence?

Yes — the Social Security (Recovery of Benefits) Act 1997 applies to all personal injury claims including clinical negligence. NHS Resolution as defendant deals with CRU in the standard way for English clinical negligence. The claim is still registered with CRU online or on form CRU1.

What if CRU amount exceeds the special damages?

The deduction from the claimant cannot exceed the award for the matching heads (s.8(3)–(4)). The compensator remains liable to pay the whole certified amount (s.6(1)). Ring-fencing of general damages: Williams v Devon CC [2003] EWCA Civ 365.

---

Further reading

• Compensation Recovery Unit (CRU) — gov.uk — Official CRU guidance and forms
• Social Security (Recovery of Benefits) Act 1997
• Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Act 2003, Part 3 — replacing the repealed Road Traffic (NHS Charges) Act 1999
• CPR Part 36 — particularly rule 36.20 on deductible benefits
• Multi-Track Personal Injury Trial Bundle: From Pleadings to Authorities
• Engineering Expert Evidence in RTA Trials: When and How to Bundle